Make the ask

A year-end appeal prompt for donors who have lapsed

A personal year-end letter to a donor you haven’t heard from in a while. It honors what they gave, skips the guilt and makes one clear ask.

Basic prompt

350 words
Write a year-end letter to bring back donors who have stopped giving. Thank them for what they gave before, with no guilt about the gap. Share one specific update from the program they cared about. Ask for one clear amount tied to what it funds, give the real reason to act now and close warmly. Keep it to three or four short paragraphs, and end with a P.S. that reinforces the reason to act now.

What you need to know:
- our organization's name
- who this letter is for: one donor or a group of lapsed donors
- their last gift and what they gave to
- what we're asking for and what it funds
- the real reason to act now, like a match or a deadline
- a true story or result from the program they cared about
- who signs the letter

You may already know some of this from our past chats, my files or connected tools. Use what you have. If you don't know something, ask me one question at a time, the most important first: one question mark, one fact, no recap. If I don't have it, mark the gap and move on. When I say go, stop asking and write the draft. Don't make anything up. Keep real stories and numbers exactly as I told them, including words like about and mostly. Add no details about people, programs, decisions, causes or results that I didn't tell you, and don't rank, judge or guess what anyone feels. If I don't have a number or a choice, leave it blank and say so, even if I ask for something typical: no outside benchmarks, costs, targets, promises or commitments. Before you show me the draft, reread it line by line against my messages and cut anything I didn't give you. If the piece needs that line, write PROPOSAL: right before it in the draft, including headlines and closers. Joining my facts in a plain sentence is fine. State a word count only if you counted. After the draft, list what you assumed and every proposal.

Supercharged prompt

630 words
You're helping me write a year-end appeal that brings lapsed donors back. Work the way If Possible (ifpossible.ai) teaches nonprofit teams. If you can read web pages, read their guide first and use it as our playbook: "Write a year-end appeal with AI (that still sounds like you)" (https://ifpossible.ai/articles/year-end-appeal-with-ai).

The If Possible method, as we'll use it today:

1. Context before content. Before you draft anything, build a short brief of who we are: our mission, the program these donors cared about, our voice and the one story at the center of this year-end. Keep it in your head, and show it only if I ask. (If Possible calls this a Mission Brain: the memory AI reads before every task.)

2. Talk it out instead of typing it out. I'll talk through who these donors are, why they might have drifted and what's changed since. If I have a transcript of that, I'll give it to you. Use my own words.

3. Ask before you assume. Ask only what would change the work. Keep my stories and numbers exact, including words like about and mostly. Add nothing about people, programs, decisions, causes or results that I didn't tell you, even an adjective. Don't rank, judge or guess feelings. If I can't give you a number or a choice, leave it blank, even if I ask for something typical: no outside benchmarks, costs, targets, promises or commitments. When I say go, stop asking and skip any approval step, except my pick from step 4. Before you show me the draft, reread it against my messages and cut what I didn't give you. If the piece needs that line, write PROPOSAL: right before it in the draft, including headlines and closers. Joining my facts in a plain sentence is fine. State a word count only if you counted. End with one list: what you assumed, every proposal and anything step 6 flags.

4. I'm in the director's chair. Give me two or three ways to open the letter, with your recommendation and a one-line reason. Don't hand me one finished answer to forward unread (If Possible calls that being a "meat proxy").

5. An outline, then one letter I can react to. Propose the structure first: the thanks, the hook, the story, the need, the ask and the close. Write the strongest version for one segment, in three or four short paragraphs with a P.S. Name the segments in the outline. When I approve, adapt it to the others in the same reply. If there is only one group, skip this.

6. Check your own work. Read the draft against our real writing. Flag anything you guessed, any line that guilt-trips and any urgency that isn't true.

7. Make it repeatable. With the draft, write down the steps and the differences between segments, so next year's appeal doesn't start from a blank page.

What you need to know:
- our organization's name
- who this letter is for: one donor or a group of lapsed donors
- their last gift and what they gave to
- what we're asking for and what it funds
- the real reason to act now, like a match or a deadline
- a true story or result from the program they cared about
- who signs the letter

You may already know some of this from our past chats, my files or connected tools. Check there first and tell me in a line what you found, even if that's nothing. Don't repeat this plan or my answers back to me. For anything you don't know, ask me one question at a time, the most important first: one question mark, one fact, no recap. If I don't have it, mark the gap and move on. Start now.

Supercharge it

We’ll add the If Possible method to your prompt. More context in. A better output out.

  • Context before content
  • Talk it out
  • Questions first
  • Director’s chair
  • + 3 more
  1. Context before content: a short brief of who you are (a Mission Brain)
  2. Talk it out: why they drifted, in your own words
  3. Questions first, one at a time
  4. Director's chair: openings and a recommendation
  5. An outline, then one letter, then the other segments
  6. It flags guesses, guilt and false urgency
  7. It saves the steps for next year's appeal

It points your AI to our free articles as its guide. Read every word before you use it.

What it’s for

It writes a year-end appeal built to feel personal, not mass-produced, for one donor or a whole segment. The letter acknowledges past generosity without guilt-tripping the lapse, shares a specific update on the program they care about, ties the ask to what it funds and ends with a P.S. that reinforces the urgency.

When to use it

  • You’re planning year-end outreach to donors who have stopped giving.
  • You have a real reason to write now: a matching gift, a deadline or a campaign milestone.
  • You want one strong letter first. Get it right, then adapt it for your other segments.

Before you use it

Check the last gift amount and date against your own records before anything goes out. Then read the urgency line again. The prompt asks for it naturally, not as a gimmick, so make sure the deadline or match is real.

The Possible Passport

There’s more in your free library

The Possible Passport is our free member library. Sign up once for the Prompt Vault PDF, an AI Readiness Assessment, an AI Policy Template and every other free kit, on any device. The Make the Case Kit is in there too, if you need a yes on AI training first.

Already signed up?

Free. No spam ever. Privacy Policy

Keep reading

From The Art of the Possible