Thank and keep donors

A five-email welcome series for new donors

Five emails over 30 days that thank a first-time donor, show the impact and set up the second gift before the first one is forgotten.

Basic prompt

333 words
Design a five-email welcome series for first-time donors that builds connection and sets up a second step before the first gift is forgotten. Day 0: thank you and immediate impact. Day 3: story and mission depth. Day 7: behind the scenes. Day 14: community and belonging. Day 30: a soft second ask. For each email, give me a subject line under 50 characters, preview text under 90 characters, copy under 200 words and button text.

What you need to know:
- our organization's name
- our main programs
- one true story of someone we serve
- a true detail from behind the scenes
- what we want a new donor to do next, like give monthly, come to an event or volunteer
- who the emails come from

You may already know some of this from our past chats, my files or connected tools. Use what you have. If you don't know something, ask me one question at a time, the most important first: one question mark, one fact, no recap. If I don't have it, mark the gap and move on. When I say go, stop asking and write the draft. Don't make anything up. Keep real stories and numbers exactly as I told them, including words like about and mostly. Add no details about people, programs, decisions, causes or results that I didn't tell you, and don't rank, judge or guess what anyone feels. If I don't have a number or a choice, leave it blank and say so, even if I ask for something typical: no outside benchmarks, costs, targets, promises or commitments. Before you show me the draft, reread it line by line against my messages and cut anything I didn't give you. If the piece needs that line, write PROPOSAL: right before it in the draft, including headlines and closers. Joining my facts in a plain sentence is fine. State a word count only if you counted. After the draft, list what you assumed and every proposal.

Supercharged prompt

585 words
You're helping me design a welcome series for first-time donors. Work the way If Possible (ifpossible.ai) teaches nonprofit teams. If you can read web pages, read their guide first and use it as our playbook: "A donor thank-you system that runs itself" (https://ifpossible.ai/articles/donor-thank-you-system).

The If Possible method, as we'll use it today:

1. Context before content. Before you draft anything, build a short brief of who we are: our mission, what a first gift makes possible, our voice and what new donors hear from us today. Keep it in your head, and show it only if I ask. (If Possible calls this a Mission Brain: the memory AI reads before every task.)

2. Talk it out instead of typing it out. I'll talk through what I wish every new donor knew about us. If I have a transcript of me talking to a donor, I'll give it to you. Use my own words.

3. Ask before you assume. Ask only what would change the work. Keep my stories and numbers exact, including words like about and mostly. Add nothing about people, programs, decisions, causes or results that I didn't tell you, even an adjective. Don't rank, judge or guess feelings. If I can't give you a number or a choice, leave it blank, even if I ask for something typical: no outside benchmarks, costs, targets, promises or commitments. When I say go, stop asking and skip any approval step, except my pick from step 4. Before you show me the draft, reread it against my messages and cut what I didn't give you. If the piece needs that line, write PROPOSAL: right before it in the draft, including headlines and closers. Joining my facts in a plain sentence is fine. State a word count only if you counted. End with one list: what you assumed, every proposal and anything step 6 flags.

4. I'm in the director's chair. Give me two or three arcs for the five emails, with your recommendation and a one-line reason. Don't hand me one finished answer to forward unread (If Possible calls that being a "meat proxy").

5. The arc first, then the emails. Show me one line on each email before you write, across 30 days. Once I approve the arc, write them in order: a subject under 50 characters, preview text under 90, copy under 200 words and button text.

6. Check your own work. Flag anything you guessed and any outcome you made up. Read all five in order and tell me where it repeats itself or asks too soon.

7. Make it repeatable. With the draft, save the series and note what should be true before we add a version for other gift levels.

What you need to know:
- our organization's name
- our main programs
- one true story of someone we serve
- a true detail from behind the scenes
- what we want a new donor to do next, like give monthly, come to an event or volunteer
- who the emails come from

You may already know some of this from our past chats, my files or connected tools. Check there first and tell me in a line what you found, even if that's nothing. Don't repeat this plan or my answers back to me. For anything you don't know, ask me one question at a time, the most important first: one question mark, one fact, no recap. If I don't have it, mark the gap and move on. Start now.

Supercharge it

We’ll add the If Possible method to your prompt. More context in. A better output out.

  • Context before content
  • Talk it out
  • Questions first
  • Director’s chair
  • + 3 more
  1. Context before content: a short brief of who you are (a Mission Brain)
  2. Talk it out: what you wish every new donor knew
  3. Questions first, one at a time
  4. Director's chair: arcs and a recommendation
  5. The arc first, then five emails in order
  6. It reads the series through for repeats and early asks
  7. It saves the series and when to expand it

It points your AI to our free articles as its guide. Read every word before you use it.

What it’s for

It designs a welcome series that builds connection and demonstrates impact: Day 0 thank you, Day 3 story and mission depth, Day 7 behind the scenes, Day 14 community and belonging, Day 30 a soft second ask. Each email comes with a subject line, preview text, full copy under 200 words and CTA button text.

When to use it

  • Your first-time donors hear little between the receipt and the next appeal.
  • You’re about to bring in new donors at year-end or on a giving day, and want the follow-up written before it arrives.
  • You have a clear idea of the second step you want: monthly giving, an event, volunteering or a second gift.

Before you use it

Speed matters most on Day 0. A fast, personal reply tells a new donor they made a good decision, and that’s what makes a second gift easy to imagine. Read all five in order and make sure a person has approved them before they go live.

The Possible Passport

There’s more in your free library

The Possible Passport is our free member library. Sign up once for the Prompt Vault PDF, an AI Readiness Assessment, an AI Policy Template and every other free kit, on any device. The Year-End Story Guide is in there too, for finding the stories donors want to hear.

Already signed up?

Free. No spam ever. Privacy Policy

Keep reading

From The Art of the Possible